E-cigarettes take off in minnesota — and so does fight over regulating them

But the new and booming industry has so far avoided regulations from the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), a fact that has some worried about any possible unknown harms in the devices. While the FDA is currently drafting recommendations on e cigarettes, some state legislatures have taken matters into their own hands. About 27 states, including Minnesota, ban e cigarettes for minors, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. Three states North Dakota, Utah and New Jersey ban smoking e cigarettes indoors.

Minnesota could soon join the ranks Rep. Phyllis Kahn, DFL Minneapolis, has introduced a bill to add e cigarettes in the Minnesota Clean Indoor Air Act, legislation she authored in 1975 to ban smoking on public property. In 2007, Minnesota lawmakers amended the act to also prohibit smoking in places of employment, restaurants and bars and in public transportation.

One of the things that s happening, and it s a good reason to do it now, there are businesses that are starting to jump on this, so you want to slow it down before it gets too widespread, Kahn said. We are not banning it, we are just putting on the brakes to say, lets look at this a bit closer.

A step backwards

According to Kahn, another benefit of her bill is it will take pressure off of local governments. So far the battle over what to do with e cigarettes has been waged on the local level. More than two dozen Minnesota cities and counties have implemented restrictions on e cigarette use in public places.

The latest city join the list is Mankato, where the City Council recently voted nearly unanimously to ban electronic cigarettes in most indoor places in the city. Hennepin County has banned smoking e cigs on county property, and Metro Transit has banned e cigarettes on all buses and trains. And there s no so called vaping allowed at Target Field, either.

Another proposal introduced this year by Rep. Laurie Halverson, DFL Eagan, would make selling e cigarettes to minors a misdemeanor, give local governments more power to regulate the devices and ban their use on public school campuses.

A major concern among skeptics is that e cigarettes sold in flavors like strawberry and bubblegum are being marketed to children and could become a pathway to cigarettes. New data from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found use of e cigarettes among middle and high school student went from 4.7 percent in 2011 to 10 percent in 2012. That has alarmed public health officials.

The Minnesota Department of Health is not working on any state level policies to regulate e cigarettes, but officials have supported local bans like in Duluth and support efforts currently introduced in the Legislature. Smoking cessation groups, like Clearway Minnesota, are against the use of e cigarettes.

We don t feel like anyone should be exposed to the vapor until we know what s in it, said Clearway spokesman Mike Sheldon. What we are looking at, if we are talking about allowing a substance with unknown harm into our air, that would be a step backwards.

Better than tobacco?

But what exactly is in the so called e juice used in the devices? Nicotine is the key functioning ingredient, although e cigarettes allow users to adjust the level of nicotine they inhale all the way down to none at all. The other main ingredients are fairly common propylene glycol, which creates the vapor seen, and glycerine, which is used in many foods as a means of preservation.

While hundreds of studies have been conducted on e cigarettes, there s no evidence the devices cause cancer. In fact, a 2011 study published in the Journal of Public Health Policy found them to be much safer than tobacco cigarettes and comparable in toxicity to conventional nicotine replacement products like nicotine patches and gum.

But other possible harmful impacts are murkier. Dorothy Hatsukami, associate director for cancer prevention and control at the University of Minnesota s Masonic Cancer Center, wants to help answer some of the lingering questions. She is leading a study examining exactly what smokers inhale when they use e cigarettes and how toxic it is compared to regular cigarettes. Researchers are working with smokers who use only e cigarettes, as well as those who use them alongside traditional cigarettes.

There have been a lot of studies done on e cigarettes, but not many have been done on the exposure of the individual themselves over a period of time, she said. There s such a wide variety of e cigarettes out on the market and some may have some unknown contaminants. Even though studies have shown there may be minimal amounts of chemicals from the vapor that s released, there s no guarantee.

E cigarette smokers head to St. Paul

But proposals to regulate their use would make Minnesota one of the toughest states on the growing industry. Oregon currently has the toughest restrictions, effectively banning the sale of two major e cigarette brands in the state until they are FDA approved or scientific research can prove them safe.

Minnesota already imposes some regulations on e cigarettes. For instance, Minnesota is the first state to label e cigarettes as an other tobacco product. That means they can tax the devices Minnesota uses an excise tax of 95 percent slapped on the wholesale cost of the product and put that revenue directly in the state s coffers. Minnesota generated about $27 million from excise taxes on other tobacco products in 2013. Minnesota also bans the sale of e cigarettes to minors.

Matt Black will be taking the e cigarette consumer argument to the Capitol next session on behalf of the Minnesota Vapers Advocacy group and the Minnesota League of Vape Shops, a trade industry group that represents about 50 storeowners. Since officially forming last August, the group has been battling on the local level.

Black, a former smoker who quit by using e cigarettes, says it should be up to the individual bar or restaurant owner if they want to allow e cigarettes in their facility. In the case of Duluth, which recently adopted restrictions on e cigarettes, users are not even allowed to use the devices in e cigarette shops.

It doesn t make sense to ban something or regulate something to death if there is no science giving you a reason to do so, Black said. But for many the impulse is, if it looks like smoke it must be smoke.

What s more, Black says it doesn t make sense to ban a product that has helped many people quit smoking. I don t think anyone realizes the faces behind this movement. It s people who want to quit smoking, Black said. They are not going out to get kids. We are fighting hard and it s all because we ve tried everything and nothing has worked until this. We don t want to see that taken away from others.

Rep. Jason Metsa, DFL Virginia, is an e cigarette user. He plans to vote against Kahn s proposal if it comes before him for a vote. The bill s first stop is in the Health and Human Services Policy Committee, in which the chairwoman, Rep. Tina Liebling, DFL Rochester, is a co author.

I ve been struggling every year to quit as a New Year s resolution. I ve found e cigarettes more helpful than anything I ve tried. At the end of the day there are no studies out there that say this is a harmful substance, said Metsa. I would want to make sure it s as readily available as long as it s not putting other people in harms way.

Smoking more than 20 cigarettes a day triples chance of
brain haemorrhage

MORE DON’T MISS

  • ‘It’s always nerve wracking, but remember’ Elizabeth Hurley urges women to get screened for breast cancer during mammogram selfie
  • Hiding his Lethal Weapons? Mel Gibson covers growing biceps as he leaves a gym in Los Angeles His life finally seems to be working out
  • Businessman James Packer rolls up for dinner at LA’s trendy vegan restaurant after VIP seal of approval from Jay Z, Beyonce and Gwyneth Paltrow
  • REVEALED How a young Jennifer Aniston had ‘torrid romance’ with her Ferris Bueller co star Charlie Schlatter back in the Nineties
  • Heavily pregnant Zoe Foster Blake hobbles around on crutches on lunch date with husband Hamish The 33 year old is 37 weeks pregnant
  • ‘It was insane’ Miley Cyrus opens up about her ‘scary’ hospitalisation… but insists she is doing ‘much better’ Hospitalised for a week
  • Taylor made! Swift steps out in a well put together vintage outfit for a day of shopping in New York Stunning in floral dress
  • She’s in a spot o’bovver! Luisa Bradshaw White sports a gashed head as she films EastEnders To star in a lesbian kiss scene with Sonia Fowler
  • Party time is over! The Block’s golden boy Scott Cam reports for duty on building site after Logie win Took away the top award on Sunday night
  • Read all about it! Jennifer Lawrence hides behind a newspaper as she heads to Paris with beau Nicholas Hoult
  • FIRST LOOK Lucy Mecklenburgh shows off her six pack in new sportswear campaign Italian sportswear brand ellesse has teamed up with former TOWIE star
  • ‘I feel sick’ Jackie Gilles storms out of Real Housewives of Melbourne reunion while Gina Liano and Andrea Moss’s showdown turns ugly
  • Daddy’s little baller! Josh Duhamel’s eight month old son Axl proves he’s the cutest L.A. Dodgers fan ever in branded bib Baby boy in blue
  • ‘I didn’t think I’d get caught!’ Dean McDermott reveals why he cheated on Tori Spelling… as he admits to ‘doing lines’
  • ‘I was bullied’ Porsha Williams says she felt ‘threatened’ by Real Housewives co star Kenya Moore following her arrest for assault Released on bail
  • Baby Becks in the making! Proud David Beckham presents son Cruz, nine, with a football trophy after his team win under 9s cup final
  • ‘My boobs are huge and my arms flabtastic’ Five months pregnant Savannah Guthrie, 42, picks apart her flaws in 360 degree mirror Body beautiful
  • Where does she find the time! Jennifer Garner to produce mystery drama about ‘immortal families’ for Bravo
  • No booze, no bread and no botox! Barbara Hershey reveals her secrets to looking incredible at 66 Looks 20 years younger
  • Tori Spelling looks slender while out with Dean McDermott as it’s revealed ‘cameras rolled inside hospital where she was treated for ulcer and migraines’
  • Megan Fox goes make up free and displays her impressive post baby body in grey leggings three months after giving birth With husband in LA
  • Tamra Barney ‘posts angry Facebook message accusing ex husband Simon of harming their kids but then deletes it’ Bitter custody battle
  • He’s back! James Franco to make cameo in Dawn Of The Planet Of The Apes during flashback scene But didn’t his character die?
  • Heavily pregnant Jenelle Evans reveals badly sunburnt belly during family day at the beach She is heading into her eighth month
  • EXCLUSIVE ‘I’m extremely happy Amal’s a lovely girl’ George Clooney’s mother Nina confirms surprise engagement Expressed her delight
  • ‘Introducing our new little man!’ Bachelor star Melissa Rycroft bonds with newborn son in heartwarming portrait The 31 year old shared the heartwarming snap
  • Tamzin Outhwaite granted ‘quickie’ divorce from Tom Ellis in just under two minutes… after he admits to adultery Married eight years
  • If you’ve got Ecclestone continues to flaunt her post baby body as she slips into a leg baring LBD Gave birth to first child a month ago
  • Amanda Bynes pictured for first time behind the wheel after getting her driver’s licence back… following suspension for hit and run and DUI
  • Green thumbs and purple hair Nicole Richie opens up about her passion for gardening as she strikes a pose in her LA backyard Unlikely pastime
  • Emma Watson swaps preppy for edgy as she sports on trend leather trousers for day out with her rugby player boyfriend Matthew Janney
  • Girl on fire! TOWIE’s Ferne McCann heats things up as she sports flame print bikini on sunshine break The 23 year old showed off her slim figure
  • Georgia May Jagger’s friends Cara Delevingne and Suki Waterhouse rally around her following the death of her stepmother L’Wren Scott
  • Bearded Alex Pettyfer steps out in lumberjack outfit as he is still yet to be confirmed for Magic Mike 2 Wild and woolly
  • Imogen Thomas shows off her bikini body after losing a dress size as she indulges in some beach gymnastics Kept up her workout regime on holiday
  • Worlds apart Robin Thicke lives it up in New Orleans while estranged wife Paula Patton looks downcast in Vancouver as they lead increasingly separate lives
  • ‘Your children love you!’ Casey Kasem’s daughter Kerri organizes a ‘birthday vigil’ as the ailing legend turns 82 in hospital A radio legend
  • A tale of two sisters Kris Jenner’s estranged sibling Karen is worlds away from Beverly Hills as she shops for trinkets in ill fitting maxi dress
  • Hundreds of One Direction fans crushed and 47 injured after frantic surge to the stage during Peru concert Band pleaded with fans
  • Not ready to Kiss and makeup Kylie Jenner hides face as she rocks vintage T shirt… while it’s revealed ‘she wants nothing to do with Selena Gomez’
  • Rihanna’s ex bodyguard files defamation lawsuit against singer as he claims she made ‘nauseatingly offensive’ statements
  • An emotional rollercoaster! Models scream, smile and scowl for the camera as photographer captures the power of human expressions
  • Still a Brit girl at heart Cher Lloyd and her husband Craig Monk co ordinate with laid back rocky looks as they head to Topshop in LA
  • Diddy’s disappearing act Music mogul went AWOL partying for seven day straight on first trip to Ibiza… and missed recording session with Madonna producer
  • PICTURED Kym Marsh kissing and holding hands with heartbroken Hollyoaks star Stephanie Waring’s ex Dan Hooper… as Corrie star denies relationship
  • Not quite a wrap! Kate Beckinsale wears pale grey coat cinched in at the waist while filming more scenes for Absolutely Anything Stars with Simon Pegg
  • Hair raising performance! Today Show reporter Richard Wilkins’ spiky ‘do trends on Twitter… and even gets its own account Centre of attention
  • It’s a dog’s life! Sienna Miller looks laid back as she and fiance Tom Sturridge take 21 month old daughter Marlowe and their dogs for a stroll
  • ‘It’s just heartbreaking’ Beyonce says there’s too much pressure on women to be beautiful in behind the scenes video for Pretty Hurts
  • Lionel Richie, 64, looks pleased with himself as he enjoys dinner date with much younger, cleavage baring girlfriend Looked half his age
  • Anything But Ordinary! Avril Lavigne goes bra less and make up free for shopping trip with husband Chad Kroeger Went back to basics
  • The Queen gives great fashion advice! Kate’s tour wardrobe triumphs as she is named most stylish British icon while Kate Moss trails in eighth place
  • Thigh ly impressive! Daisy Lowe works a rockabilly look as she wears spray on jeans and leather jacket while running errands Figure of a 1950s pin up
  • ‘I don’t want to be the new Rihanna. I’m just a singer songwriter’ Britain’s richest woman launches pop career on Richard Madeley’s radio show
  • Beyonce and Jay Z wear matching balaclavas in new poster announcing their summer tour On The Run Joining forces
  • Hip Hop world mourns the loss of It Takes Two star DJ E Z Rock after he is found dead at 46 The producer, real name Rodney Bryce, passed away on Sunday
  • SEBASTIAN SHAKESPEARE Poppy keeps the peace with Sienna and mum The trio caught up for lunch at Picadilly
  • Already dating! Singer Kesha is spotted kissing a bearded mystery man during flea market stop only seven weeks after leaving rehab for eating disorder treatment
  • ‘When I play a real person I like to have bits of them’ Tom Hardy reveals he wears Elton John’s clothes in preparation for new biopic
  • Pregnant Kate Silverton, 43, is glamorous and glowing as she arrives with daughter Clemency to discuss SECOND miracle baby
  • ‘She left me because I’m bankrupt’ Tila Tequila’s baby daddy Thomas Paxton Whitaker reveals ‘she’s already dumped him’
  • Taking the plunge Kate Hudson wears daring low cut sequined jumpsuit to celebrate birthday with fianc Matt Bellamy Celebrating her 35th
  • Mariah Carey sheds her baby weight on the ‘purple diet’ New foodie fad encourages dieters eat only lilac produce but is it really a healthy way to lose pounds?
  • Lovely bubbly! Chrissy Teigen poses naked in bathtub as she reveals the ‘craziest place’ she and John Legend have had sex In Cosmopolitan
  • The MANE attraction! Gordon Ramsay sparks new hair transplant rumours with questionable hairstyle at Victoria Beckham’s 40th birthday meal in Mayfair
  • Meet Natasha Archer, the PA turned royal dresser who helped the Duchess of Cambridge transform from girl next door to stylish princess
  • Victoria’s Secret Angel Hilary Rhoda shares naked snap of her mottled back after becoming latest celebrity to try out cupping
  • Kendall Jenner flashes her toned midriff in crop top amid rumours she is shooting Calvin Klein ad with Justin Bieber Both fit in Calvins
  • Taking the lead Doting David Beckham wraps his blazer around wife Victoria as they leave her 40th birthday party together Married 14 years
  • Girls just wanna have fun! Cara Delevingne and Suki Waterhouse lark about in the street as they emerge from breakfast with Georgia May Jagger
  • That’s one way to keep mum Billie Faiers covers up baby bump with her designer bag as she meets sister Sam at their boutique Expecting her first child
  • ‘It’s like buying a Ferrari and keeping it in the garage!’ Good Morning Britain viewers complain Susanna Reid is stuck behind a desk… But later moved to sofa
  • Tiddly Spice Girls stumble out of Victoria Beckham’s 40th birthday at 2am… and single guy Chris Martin joins in the fun too Partied in London
  • Splashing out! Tom Daley and boyfriend Dustin Lance Black enjoy romantic evening together Partied at the Chinawhite nightclub in London
  • Anna Wintour, Alexandra Shulman and Twiggy join fashion’s finest at memorial service for former Vogue editor Beatrix Miller
  • Simon Cowell cradles little Eric while leaving upscale restaurant as he enjoys quality time with son The 54 year old proving to be a hands on dad
  • Kara Tointon highlights her slim frame with voluminous locks and retro minidress as she presents at BAFTA Television Awards Spot of retro glamour
  • She’s getting into the Hollywood spirit! EastEnders actress Patsy Palmer turns heads in elegant black dress at the BAFTA Television Craft Awards
  • Wetting appetites! US singer Ashanti makes a splash by sharing poolside pictures of her impressive bikini body Ashanti is known for her slim but curvy physique
  • The couple that pray together, stay together Vanessa Hudgens wears floaty frock as she heads to church with boyfriend Austin Butler
  • Solange Knowles ‘Beyonce’s work ethic is absolutely insane and the way she balances her career with motherhood is so inspiring’
  • From stately to static home! Prince Charles gets a warm welcome as he tours caravan park Spent a sunny couple of hours in Aberdeenshire
  • I Will Never Let You Down Rita Ora says she’s smitten with boyfriend Calvin Harris as she wears two very different looks for TV appearance in New York
  • ‘I’ve got to not blame anyone else’ Chris Martin reveals how his own personal issues contributed to the breakup with his wife Gwyneth Paltrow
  • Strictly Come Dancing star Aliona Vilani ties the knot to sales director in private wedding ceremony on Caribbean island St Thomas Beach wedding
  • Showing it off! Pregnant Mila Kunis flashes her belly in flimsy top as she cosies up to Ashton Kutcher at Stagecoach Enjoying country tunes
  • ‘No one could deserve this’ Liam Payne is overcome with emotion at sight of thousands of fans as One Direction’s world tour kicks off In Lima, Peru
  • Katy Perry delights in cherry blossom print dress as she poses with Neil Patrick Harris after his Broadway show Stars in Hedwig And The Angry Inch
  • How ‘London’s hottest barrister’ is about to become the new Mrs Clooney The rise and rise of Lebanese born lawyer set to marry the eligible bachelor
  • Pregnant Jacqui Ainsley shows off her gravity defying bump in a little black lace dress at Victoria Beckham’s 40th birthday dinner with fianc Guy Ritchie
  • ‘It’s unapologetically sexy with a dash of naughtiness’ Giles Deacon’s lingerie range for Ann Summers with bra straps that double up as handcuffs!
  • Hermes for my little homme! Melissa George dresses her new born in designer booties Seems it’s important to look your best no matter what age
  • ‘No bulls t’ Dan Hooper shares raunchy photo of him kissing Kym Marsh on Twitter after… she denied their relationship Worth a 1000 words…
  • ‘My wedding day will be the biggest of my non competitive life!’ Olympian Chemmy Alcott talks nuptials as she poses with fianc Dougie Crawford
  • At her lowest weight! Jessica Simpson celebrates even leaner frame in sheer top and skinny jeans while out for dinner… after losing 50 pounds this year
  • Giving the finger! Rihanna wears giant rubber hand to cheer on Nets as she bares midriff in army print crop top and skirt Loyal fan
  • ‘And the birthday bash continues!’ Joanna Krupa returns to Miami as she keeps the party going by celebrating turning 35 with husb
    and Romain Zago
  • Ed Sheeran My big night out with Shane Warne how Australians are more debaucherous than Brits and why Sydney Entertainment Centre is my best venue
  • Smiling through the pain Danica McKellar shows off her broken rib and support brace as she gets back to DWTS rehearsals following devastating injury
  • Pick me! Idina Menzel says she would ‘absolutely’ play Elsa in Broadway’s Frozen but she ‘doesn’t look good blonde’
  • Better LACE than never! Sophia Bush cuts a stylish figure in provocative dress with matching kinky boots Recently posed for a men’s magazine
  • Khloe Kardashian looks sexy in leopard dress for dinner date with beau French Montana… but brings BFF Malika Haqq along as third wheel
  • Nicole Scherzinger slips into monochrome jacket and figure hugging pencil skirt as she dines out with girlfriends At hotspot, Craig’s
  • Hopelessly devoted to Grease! Fox orders three hour LIVE version of the hit 1970s high school musical to air in 2015 It better shape up