Poor new yorkers spend 25% of income on cigarettes

It sucks to be poor. It sucks to smoke (broadly speaking). But most of all, it sucks to be a poor smoker in New York. This is the finding from a study conducted by RTI’s Public Health Policy Research Program which shows that low income smokers in New York spend 25 percent of their income on cigarettes, a finding that led a smokers’ rights advocate to say it proves high taxes are regressive and ineffective. Bloomberg reports «In New York, with the nation’s highest cigarette taxes, a pack of cigarettes can cost $12, though many smokers have turned to cheaper cigarettes bought online and by using roll your own devices. Wealthier smokers those earning $60,000 or more spend 2 percent on cigarettes, according to the study.» The imminent solution hike taxes even more of course. After all it is not like broke New York City needs the cash broke smokers will stop using EBT cards and other forms of cheap credit to feed addictions. And while at it, hike school tuitions a little more in a society in which the only peddled hope of regaining the American dream is graduation with an advanced pottery degree, and in which (non dischargeable) student debt costs nothing, what is the downside?

Amusingly, it seems America has something resembling a smoker’s union

for smokers, the study proves cigarette taxes are punitive and «undeniably regressive,» said Audrey Silk of CLASH, a national smokers’ rights organization.

«It busts their theory that high taxes equal submission to their coercive measure at the same time,» she said. She criticized government «anti smokers» who jack up taxes, but she also found with anti smoking groups like the Cancer Society.

«Ulterior motives abound … to generate bad news as reason to tighten the screws and fish for more funding to do it with,» she said. «They enrich themselves at the expense of those they helped stigmatize.»

The government however refuses to take the bait

Peter Constantakes of the state Health Department argues that tax increases and other programs are helping people kick the habit.

«Cigarette taxes are an evidence based intervention that has proven successful in encouraging smokers to quit,» he said. «New York is promoting a number of anti smoking initiatives, including targeted media campaigns, that are designed to reduce the smoking rate among lower income groups and prevent young people from becoming smokers.»

Apparently not, especially when handouts in various forms such as EBT cards, foodstamps and the like, do not serve as a sufficient incentive to put the cigarette down, and merely transfer money from easy sources of credit to cash strapped entities who can tax the living daylights out of credit incurring intermediaries.

But if monetary considerations do not stop smokers from lighting up, the government can just say it tried its best and begin regulating daily smoking intake in addition to everything else. Naturally that would crush vice tax revenues by the same broke striken through entities observed above. And in a world in which there is virtually no organic cash flow left, this simply will not stand.

Menthol cigarettes

S M T W T F S 1 The Computer Guys And GalScott Weems «Ha! The Science Of When We Laugh And Why» 2 Election Wrap Up Breaking Down D.C.’s PrimariesMichael Lewis «Flash Boys» 3 Fort Hood Shooting UpdateThe Longevity GapYour Turn 4 The Politics Hour April 4, 2014 5 6 7 Gallaudet University’s 150th AnniversaryAmerica’s Newest Veterans and Fort HoodUSAID Tied To Secret «Cuban Twitter» Operation 8 Personal Banking TechnologyAfghans Await Presidential Election Results Silver Line Update 9 Sine Die Maryland Legislative Wrap UpTax Time Headaches for Same Sex CouplesChef Carla Hall 10 Shaping the City Developing the Southwest WaterfrontUpdate Suspected Nazi Looted Art Returned to CollectorNew Yorker Cartoon Editor Bob Mankoff 11 The Politics Hour 12 13 14 The Director of Smithsonian’s Museum of Natural HistoryNew Rules on Handling Sexual Assault in New Images of War 15 Protecting Against A New Online Security Threat Social Security Changes Course on Old DebtsJohn Feinstein Baseball’s Minor Leagues 16 Deforestation and Climate ChangeFood and Faith Meals for Passover and Easter 17 Contemporary Religion on Capitol Hill 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30